Prominent sports journalist Rafiqul Islam believes the Bangladesh Football Federation (BFF) has focused too heavily on achieving short-term success. -BFF
The latest SAFF disappointment exposes Bangladesh's dependence on expatriate footballers and highlights the urgent need for grassroots development and long-term planning.
The arrival of Hamza Choudhury, Shamit Shome and other expatriate footballers has generated renewed enthusiasm for Bangladesh football. Expectations were particularly high ahead of the latest SAFF Championship in Dhaka, as the national team appeared stronger and more competitive than in previous years. However, despite an impressive start, Bangladesh once again failed to reach the final, extending their wait for a SAFF title that dates back to 2003.
Victories over Bhutan (1-0) and Sri Lanka (4-0) raised hopes of ending the 23-year drought. But Pakistan shattered that dream with an 86th-minute goal in the semi-final. While India eventually secured their third consecutive championship, Bangladesh were left confronting familiar questions about their footballing future.
The disappointment was not merely about losing a match. It exposed the limitations of a strategy increasingly dependent on expatriate recruits rather than developing a sustainable domestic football structure.
The Expatriate Formula Has Its Limits
There is little doubt that overseas footballers have strengthened Bangladesh's national team. Hamza has brought international experience and quality, while Shamit Shome has added strength to the midfield. Their presence has also helped restore public interest in the national side.
However, Bangladesh fielded eight expatriate players in their starting eleven against Pakistan and still failed to overcome an opponent ranked lower in the FIFA standings.
Prominent sports journalist Rafiqul Islam believes the Bangladesh Football Federation (BFF) has focused too heavily on achieving short-term success.
"First and foremost, this failure stems from the lack of development in Bangladeshi football. The BFF pursued a strategy aimed at achieving quick, shortcut success while failing to take meaningful initiatives to develop homegrown talent," he observed.
"If I compare this side with the team that won the SAFF Championship in 2003, I do not think the present squad measures up. We have one or two outstanding players, but we lack a cohesive, compact unit," he said.
The semi-final against Pakistan demonstrated this weakness. Bangladesh enjoyed approximately 60 per cent possession but struggled to create meaningful attacking opportunities. Pakistan maintained a five-man defensive line and relied on counter-attacks.
According to Rafiqul, Pakistan's coach had carefully analysed Bangladesh's earlier performances and specifically planned to neutralize Hamza, Shamit Shome and Farhan Ali Wahid.
Their tactical discipline, physical strength and stamina ultimately made the difference.
Bangladesh's elimination was sealed when goalkeeper Mehedi Hasan Shrabon's poorly directed throw-in allowed Abdul Samad to score in the 86th minute.
Although Shrabon faced considerable criticism, the defensive breakdown involved other players as well. Several Bangladesh footballers moved towards the right flank, leaving a significant gap in midfield that Pakistan exploited.
Rafiqul believes the goalkeeper has received excessive criticism.
"We conceded in the 86th minute, but what had we achieved during the preceding 85 minutes? We had not created enough significant attacking opportunities," he remarked, adding that Shrabon had made two excellent saves earlier in the match.
Player fatigue and inadequate preparation also contributed to the defeat. Bangladesh had only three days between their final group match and the semi-final, whereas Pakistan enjoyed five days of preparation. Shamit appeared particularly fatigued, while Hamza also made several uncharacteristic mistakes.
Hamza's Growing Responsibility
Hamza has become the central figure in Bangladesh's football revival. However, the team's increasing dependence on him presents another concern.
"Since Hamza's arrival, both supporters and the team have developed enormous expectations of him. He has lived up to those expectations, contributing both offensively and defensively," Rafiqul said.
He believes expatriate recruitment is not inherently problematic, but the quality of players must remain the priority. Some younger recruits, including Zidan Yusuf and Farhan Ali Wahid, are still developing their careers.
Rafiqul also recalled Bangladesh's nine-goal defeat against Indonesia in the ASEAN Cup as another indication of the country's footballing weaknesses.
India's third consecutive SAFF triumph offers another perspective. Despite arriving with a second-string squad, they maintained their regional dominance, reflecting a broader football development programme and greater international ambitions.
Bangladesh, meanwhile, remain heavily focused on regional success.
State Minister for Youth and Sports Aminul Haque, a member of Bangladesh's 2003 SAFF-winning team, expressed disappointment over the latest semi-final defeat. He had hoped the current generation would repeat the achievement but remained optimistic about future success.
Ultimately, Bangladesh need more than expatriate stars to revive their football. A competitive domestic league, functioning district competitions, youth academies, quality coaching and regular international exposure must become priorities.
The arrival of Hamza and other overseas players has created an opportunity to raise standards. But their contributions should complement, not replace, the development of local talent.
Bangladesh have waited more than two decades for another SAFF crown. The latest disappointment offers a clear lesson: winning a tournament requires more than assembling talented individuals. It requires a complete football system capable of producing players who can compete and win together.
Until that foundation is established, the wait for SAFF glory may continue.
Latest News