Julia Petrova
Turkey's political identity has long been shaped by an uneasy struggle between secular republicanism, Islamic conservatism, democratic aspirations, and authoritarian tendencies. Situated at the crossroads of Europe and Asia, the country has attempted to reconcile its Ottoman-Islamic heritage with the secular foundations established by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk. However, the political transformation that has taken place under President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has raised a fundamental question: How long can Turkey sustain a political system that combines religious conservatism, electoral legitimacy, selective liberalism, and increasingly centralized executive power?
The expression "liberal theocracy" is not a formal description of Turkey's constitutional structure. Turkey remains constitutionally a secular republic, and its political institutions are not officially governed by religious law. Nevertheless, the growing influence of religious conservatism in public administration, education, cultural policy, and political discourse has created a complicated system in which Islamic values play an increasingly important role in shaping national identity and governance. At the same time, competitive elections, private enterprise, international trade, and diplomatic engagement with Western countries remain important features of Turkish society.
This contradiction makes Turkey an interesting but increasingly complicated political experiment. Its government seeks to preserve the legitimacy of democratic elections while strengthening a conservative national identity and consolidating political authority. The sustainability of this arrangement will depend on whether the government can maintain economic stability, protect institutional credibility, accommodate social diversity, and respond to the expectations of younger generations.
The roots of this transformation can be traced to the rise of the Justice and Development Party (AKP), which came to power in 2002. Initially, Erdogan and his political allies presented themselves as reformers committed to economic modernization, political pluralism, and Turkey's integration with the European Union. Their early years in office brought economic growth, infrastructure development, and a stronger international profile. The government also challenged the traditional dominance of the military establishment, which had repeatedly intervened in Turkish politics in the name of defending secularism.
However, the relationship between political Islam and democratic governance gradually became more complicated. Erdogan's administration increasingly concentrated executive authority, weakened institutional checks and balances, and placed greater emphasis on religious and nationalist narratives. The constitutional changes that introduced an executive presidential system in 2018 significantly expanded presidential powers. Critics argue that the resulting political structure has undermined parliamentary oversight and reduced the independence of institutions that should hold the government accountable. A 2026 constitutional study published by Oxford Academic also describes Turkey's transformation as a movement toward an increasingly illiberal constitutional identity.
OUP Academic+1
One of the most significant features of this political transformation is the expanding influence of religious institutions. The Directorate of Religious Affairs, commonly known as Diyanet, has become an influential state institution, extending its activities beyond traditional religious administration. Its involvement in religious education, public communication, and national ceremonies reflects the government's determination to give Sunni Islamic values a more prominent position in public life.
The education sector has also become an important arena for ideological transformation. Religious schools have received considerable institutional attention, while Islamic teachings have acquired greater visibility in the national education system. The government's ambition to cultivate a more religiously conscious generation has generated considerable debate among secular families, educators, and civil society organizations. Although religious education is a legitimate component of any pluralistic society, concerns emerge when state institutions appear to favor one religious interpretation over others.
BTI 2026+1Turkey's complicated relationship with religious minorities further illustrates the limitations of its political model. The country has a diverse religious heritage, including Alevis, Christians, Jews, and other communities. Nevertheless, allegations of unequal institutional treatment and restrictions on religious freedom have remained persistent. A state that promotes religious conservatism while claiming to represent all citizens must demonstrate that citizenship rights do not depend on religious identity. Otherwise, its national unity narrative risks becoming increasingly exclusionary.
The country's economic circumstances also pose a serious challenge to the durability of the present political arrangement. Turkey has considerable industrial capacity, a strategic geographical position, a strong tourism sector, and extensive commercial connections with Europe, the Middle East, and Central Asia. However, prolonged currency depreciation, inflationary pressures, and uncertainty over economic policymaking have created difficulties for ordinary households and businesses.
For a political establishment seeking legitimacy through both electoral support and national religious identity, economic performance remains indispensable. Citizens may tolerate ideological differences when employment opportunities expand, purchasing power improves, and public services function effectively. But religious rhetoric cannot indefinitely compensate for declining living standards. Young people struggling with unemployment, housing costs, and limited economic opportunities are unlikely to judge political leadership solely through appeals to traditional values.
Another important question concerns the future of political opposition. Turkey's opposition parties have repeatedly demonstrated that conservative political dominance is not necessarily irreversible. The Republican People's Party (CHP), traditionally associated with secular republicanism, achieved significant victories in the March 2024 municipal elections, demonstrating that economic dissatisfaction and demands for accountable government can transcend ideological divisions.
However, the subsequent political environment has become increasingly difficult for opposition politicians. Istanbul Mayor Ekrem Imamoglu, a prominent political rival of Erdogan, was detained in March 2025 and has remained imprisoned pending trial on corruption-related charges that he denies. The government maintains that judicial proceedings are independent, while opposition leaders describe the cases as politically motivated. In 2026, further legal and organizational disputes weakened the opposition landscape.
Human Rights Watch+3These developments raise questions about whether electoral competition can remain meaningful when prominent political challengers face substantial legal and institutional obstacles. Democracy cannot survive merely through periodic voting. It requires independent courts, freedom of expression, a competitive media environment, and protection for political organizations. If citizens increasingly believe that elections cannot produce meaningful political change, public confidence in democratic institutions may deteriorate.
The media environment represents another critical weakness. Independent journalism is essential for exposing corruption, scrutinizing public expenditure, and informing citizens about government decisions. Yet journalists and opposition-oriented media organizations have faced mounting pressure. Recent raids and administrative interventions involving opposition-aligned broadcasters have intensified concerns about media independence. The government rejects allegations of political interference, but the broader pattern has raised serious questions about the ability of journalists to operate without intimidation.
AP News+1
International relations could also influence the future of Turkey's political experiment. As a NATO member with considerable military and diplomatic influence, Turkey occupies an important position in regional and international affairs. Its relationships with the United States, European Union, Russia, and Middle Eastern countries require a pragmatic foreign policy that cannot be sustained through ideological considerations alone.
European integration remains particularly complicated. Turkey's geographical position, industrial potential, and economic connections make cooperation with European countries mutually beneficial. However, continuing concerns about judicial independence, political freedoms, and democratic standards have undermined its European aspirations. The European Commission's 2026 assessment identified continuing democratic backsliding and serious deficiencies in the separation of powers.
Eur-Lex+1
Nevertheless, it would be a mistake to assume that Turkish society is uniformly opposed to religious conservatism or that secularism automatically enjoys universal public support. Millions of citizens genuinely value Erdogan's political leadership, his emphasis on Islamic identity, and his determination to strengthen Turkey's international standing. Many also remember the economic improvements and infrastructure development associated with the AKP's earlier years. Any sustainable political alternative must recognize these sentiments rather than treating religious conservatism as an obstacle that can simply be eliminated.
The real question, therefore, is not whether Turkey should embrace secularism at the expense of religion or religion at the expense of secularism. It is whether the state can guarantee equal citizenship, institutional accountability, and individual freedom regardless of personal beliefs. A democratic republic should neither marginalize religious citizens nor impose the preferences of a religious majority on everyone else.
Turkey's future will ultimately depend on its ability to reconcile competing national identities through constitutional democracy. Religious conservatism may remain an influential political force for generations, but its legitimacy must be measured by its capacity to coexist with pluralism, freedom, and accountable government.
How long can Turkey hold on to its so-called liberal theocracy? There is no definite timetable. Its endurance will depend less on the political popularity of religious nationalism than on the government's ability to deliver economic security, preserve social cohesion, and maintain public confidence. A political system that combines electoral legitimacy with religious conservatism may survive for a considerable period, but one that sacrifices democratic accountability to preserve concentrated power will eventually face growing resistance. Turkey's greatest challenge is not choosing between Islam and secularism; it is ensuring that neither becomes an excuse for denying citizens their fundamental democratic rights.
Julia Petrova is an entrepreneur and social
welfare activist based in Moscow.
Latest News